But, let’s not forget that at the heart of the Lavinia Byrne case was her refusal to accept Catholic teaching on the question of whether women can be priests. And on this question the Church’s doctrine has been utterly consistent since the beginning of the Christian era: namely that the Church has no authority to ordain women. This was confirmed by Pope John Paul II in 1994. He made it very clear that this was not a new dogma, but a very old one. To teach the contrary, he declared, is “equivalent to leading consciences into error.”
The ladies below need not have had any worries, I think. In fact, one look would have sent you running for the bottle. As someone once said to me, the strongest argument against ordaining women might be the women who actually want to be ordained!
Tuesday, 1 March 2011
Mgr Loftus on 'poor Lavinia Byrne'!
Monday, 28 February 2011
Requiescat in Pace - Bishop Augustine Hu Daguo
Requiescat in Pace
Bishop Augustine Hu Daguo
of the apostolic prefecture of Shiqian, Shihtsien,
in the Chinese province of Guizhou,
died on February 17 at the age of 90.
Meanwhile our governments continue to trade and be polite to the Chinese government for the sake of burger concessions and car sales - to say nothing of the disgrace of holding the Olympics there - while they continue to enforce abortion in their one child only family policy and imprison Catholics for loyalty to the Pope.
Sunday, 27 February 2011
Vatican II and the Extraordinary Mgr Loftus

Pope John XXIII opening the Second Vatican Council
in an obvious move to simplify the ceremonial of the Church
The Monsignor draws on Wordsworth's excited and laudatory description of the French Revolution to make a comparison with the Second Vatican Council - although the quote from The Prelude (1805) is incorrect, I think it should read "Bliss it was in that dawn to be alive". Bad form, I would say, to misquote someone in a book review! (Wordsworth was later to become completely disillusioned with events in France.)
Considering the bloody outcome for many and the difficult consequences for the Church, I would have thought it was not a very flattering comparison. However, on closer inspection, we might draw out some interesting parallels. It may well have been that there were just causes for the grievances against their rulers that led to the French Revolution. The ideals that inspired it may have been laudable but very quickly much that was done in its name was shameful and completely removed from those ideals. What the Second Vatican Council called for may have been quite necessary and the inspiration behind the documents very laudable but some of what has followed and been done in its name is shameful and completely removed from those ideals.
We might pause to remember that the ultimate inspiration behind the Council and its documents is the Holy Spirit. Our Lord guaranteed that in founding His Church. However, the actual documents are the only things guaranteed by that unsurpassable source - anything vague and done "in the spirit" of the Council must prove its provenance by direct quotes from the Council Documents for many now believe that we have departed from its mandates.
We might also pause to recall that since the Council and what has been done in its name, the Church has not exactly been flourishing. The closure in every town and city of this country of our convents, monasteries, churches and seminaries are clear evidence of that. The elephant in the corner that everyone is too polite to mention. Many who invested themselves in the idea of change and all that's new must be good did so out of praiseworthy motives but now that our churches are empty, they can't go back on a lifetime invested in those very changes. The greatest among them have been able to see that it wasn't working and our Holy Father is a prime example of this. Of course, those on the extreme liberal wing maintain the decline is because the Council's intentions have been diverted and we haven't gone far enough in dismantling the past. Perhaps all we are awaiting is a liberal Robespierre to bring its true intentions to fruition.
Those like the Monsignor of Leeds however write from a well-known and obvious liberal bias (if not to say freely-admitted communist influence bias, in this case ) and it shows through nowhere more clearly than in his assessment of some documents of the Council. The liberal agenda chooses those it can interpret to its own advantage and lauds them but rejects other documents - despite them all coming out of the same Spirit-filled Council. Thus from the review comes this little gem:
Not all the conciliar documents are covered. Those, for instance on Education and the Communications media are disappointing and inadequate, not to say, in some instances, harmful.To describe the decrees of the Second Vatican Council as "harmful" would seem to place the holder of such views in a rather difficult position in regard to the Church. The furore last year was when the Monsignor threatened to sue when he was called a heretic. Are his views heretical?
........You might very well think that...
.............I couldn't possibly comment.
(In fact this article was brought to my attention by a friend, a former parishioner of the good Mgr, who must remain anonymous - Mgr Loftus threatened to sue him more than once! Ah! The live-and-let live attitude of the freewheeling modern priest.)
Thursday, 24 February 2011
Introibo ad altare Dei
Pictures from the Mass above and the homily is below, as so many people were kind enough to ask for a copy that I thought this was the easiest way to disseminate it.
In the early evening of 19 April 2005 myself, another priest and the Master of ceremonies awaited in the sitting room of my parish, with baited breath, the election of a new Successor of St Peter. When the name of Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger was announced we were, it has to be said, ecstatic. I didn’t know whether to run and open the champagne already chilling for such happy news or to rush to the church and give praise to God. In fact, we went to the church first to dismantle the catafalque and six unbleached candles surrounding it that had been standing in the sanctuary since Pope John Paul’s death and set up the altar for a Mass of Thanksgiving. The church had no bells but the people knew well enough to turn up at hearing the news and so we celebrated Mass with a goodly congregation of about 50 people. Thus began for me the reign of Pope Benedict XVI.
Not the reign of the Panzar Cardinal, of course - an image conjured up by the liberal media and fed by their counterparts within the Church but the reign of a man deeply aware of the needs of the Church and the terrible evil of the dictatorship of relativism that has been inflicting its relentless agenda on Europe since the so-called “Enlightenment” and which has infected even God’s holy Church:
"Today, a particularly insidious obstacle to the task of education is the massive presence in our society and culture of that relativism which, recognising nothing as definitive, leaves as the ultimate criterion only the self with its desires. And under the semblance of freedom it becomes a prison for each one, for it separates people from one another, locking each person into his or her own ego."
In other words, we each create our own little world-view and it is inevitably limited, narrow and bound up only with our own concerns.
Engaging the battle with this modern evil (the direct successor of the Modernism condemned by Pope St Pius X) has been at the heart of Pope Benedict’s pontificate. I think that one of the means he sees of doing this is to draw into powerful unity within the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church all who should be there - both dissenters within the Church and those outside the full unity of communion with the See of Peter. He says in his letter accompanying the Moto Proprio about the Traditional Mass:
"I now come to the positive reason which motivated my decision to issue this Motu Proprio. It is a matter of coming to an interior reconciliation in the heart of the Church. Looking back over the past, one continually has the impression that, at critical moments when divisions were coming about, not enough was done by the Church’s leaders to maintain or regain reconciliation and unity. This glance at the past imposes an obligation on us today: to make every effort to enable for all those who truly desire unity to remain in that unity or to attain it anew."
Thus it is that we have recently seen the invitation into the Church to those Anglicans who are willing to be rescued in the Barque of Peter. And the Moto Proprio Summorum Pontificum is yet another facet of that same concern, for it opens the way to a return to full unity to those who are attached to the Traditional Mass who had gone their own way. But it is not just a crumb thrown to them or the window dressing of an ecclesiastical spin-doctor, for it has changed the mood of the Church itself, the feel, the timbré, of who we are and where we are going, of what is and is not acceptable. The Church is now different and that is why its approach to others and their approach to us is different. I say “different” from what is was in the recent past but not new - for the difference is that we are once more in touch with our heritage, our Traditio
· and I include in that rootedness in the past, the Gospels themselves and the saving events they describe.
Here is the real reason we can never be a church that understands itself by a hermeneutic of disruption or discontinuity with the past. For the past, those saving events, are our reason for being here and they are not in the past at all - they are made present to us by the saving Sacrifice of the Mass, where we stand at the foot of the cross and at the open tomb together with every man and woman who has knelt before the altar since then.
Cardinal Pacelli, the future Pope Pius XII put is succinctly when he said to Count Geleazzi, in relation to the warnings of Fatima:
"I am concerned about the confidences of the Virgin to the little Lucia of Fatima. The persistence of the Good Lady in face of the danger that threatens the Church is a divine warning against the suicide that the modification of the Faith, liturgy, theology, and soul of the Church would represent.
I hear around me partisans of novelties who want to demolish the Holy Sanctuary, destroy the universal flame of the Church, reject her adornments, and make her remorseful for her historical past. Well, my dear friend, I am convinced that the Church of Peter must affirm her past, or else she will dig her own tomb.
I will fight this battle with the greatest energy both inside and outside the Church, even if the forces of evil may one day take advantage of my person, actions, or writings, as they try today to deform the History of the Church".
It is surely an awareness of this continuity, this communion, with all the previous generations of Christians - and future generations - that gives us our strength and that shows up most starkly that we cannot each make up our own selfish little world view. And it is in the Mass of Ages that this is most beautifully expressed. As the Holy Father says:
"In the history of the liturgy there is growth and progress, but no rupture. What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us too, and it cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful. It behooves all of us to preserve the riches which have developed in the Church’s faith and prayer, and to give them their proper place."
The Mass that is recognisable to all ages is the very antithesis of relativism. Even the ordained minister of the Sacrament - be he priest, bishop or Pope is submerged and subsumed into it and at its service. The vestments and the whole ritual of the Mass hide the man and show forth the Saviour.
It is an awareness of these eternal and universal (Catholic) values that coalesce in the Mass and call us back to our foundation, our rock, Christ himself - rooted in history and yet of cosmic significance. The Holy Father must, I think, see in the Mass which we celebrate tonight - on this feast of the teaching and ruling office of the Popes - something that will strengthen and assist the re-foundation of the fullness of the Faith that is missing from so many Christian hearts in our day. As we pray, so we shall believe and live.
Today is the feast of the teaching and ruling authority of the Vicar of Christ and so it should be no surprise that the call to action, to unity to the fullness of faith issues forth from the successor of St Peter. There is the place to which we must look to keep our hearts and minds at one with all those down the ages who have come to the altar of God. And just when the gates of hell might seem to prevail is precisely when the words of Christ to Peter should thunder in our ears. If you too would prevail against the gates of hell, then you must stand at Peter’s side:
Thou art Peter and upon this rock I will build my Church and the gates of hell will not prevail against it.
AMDG
Tuesday, 22 February 2011
"the strong obey when a strong man shows them the way"
"with an unshakeable affection for the Successor of Peter and with the desire to strengthen and maintain the communion which binds the Church in charity around him."
My mind wandered to the song "Stout-hearted men" (Lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein) and especially the lines:
"stout-hearted for whatever awaits in the future."
"Hearts can inspire other hearts with their fire,
For the strong obey when a strong man shows them the way.

Give me some men who are stout-hearted men,
Who will fight, for the right they adore,
Start me with ten who are stout-hearted men,
And I'll soon give you ten thousand more."
Here are "ten who are stout-hearted men" (Most of them are speaking at the Adoratio Conference in Rome, June 20 - 24th )










Sunday, 20 February 2011
Why am I afraid to tell you who I am?
"In our time, in which the Faith in many places seems like a light in danger of being snuffed out forever, the highest priority is to make God visible in the world and to open to humanity a way to God. And not to any god, but to the God who had spoken on Sinai; the God whose face we recognize in the love borne to the very end (cf. Jn 13:1) in Jesus Christ, crucified and risen.Further to the controversy over the Cardinal Vaughan Memorial School, the parents have distributed a leaflet in the various parishes where they attend. I say "various" because, unlike most Catholic Schools, the Vaughan takes families from many parishes and uses not geography but practice of the Faith as entrance criteria. (You can read the contents of the leaflet here at James Preece's blog.) What a novel idea - you are able to go top a catholic school not beacuse you happen to live nearby (regardless of faith issues) but because you are a catholic who practices their Faith and is involved in their parish. How revolutionary!
Dear brothers and sisters, worship Christ the Lord in your hearts (cf. 1 Pet 3:15)! Do not be afraid to talk of God and to manifest without fear the signs of Faith, letting the light of Christ shine in the presence of the people of today, just as the Church which gives birth to humanity as the family of God sings on the night of the Easter Vigil."
Benedict XVI, FATIMA, Portugal, MAY 12, 2010
What particularly drew my attention are the following two points:
The Diocese of Westminster has forced schools such as The Cardinal Vaughan Memorial School (CVMS) to drop from their admission criteria the requirement for parents to present their children for the Sacraments of First Holy Communion and Confession.
Practising Catholic families question why this requirement of Canon Law has not been insisted upon by the Diocese.
Mass for the Chair of St Peter


(In fact, the history of the College goes back to it's predecessor at Douay founded in 1568 by Cardinal Allen - so 443 years.)
Anyway, the picture above (from 1894) shows the Entrance Hall (now compromised with PC fire safety doors). In th' olden days, where the red lino on the stairs began no seminarian's foot could tread - Profs only! (That's me on the left!)





