Saturday, 19 February 2011

Catholic (?) Schools - What would Our Lady say?

The Shrine of Our Lady of Good Help

Continuing from my post about the Radio 4 "Today" programme on the Cardinal Vaughan School last week, one of the other things said by the "professional expert" Professor Grace is that "It is not their school [the parents] - the school belongs to the Diocese".

Ches at thesensiblebond comments very effectively that this is not really the case.

it is worth pointing out that they all share in the same fundamentally wrong assumption if the Catholic Church runs an education service, parents should come to it, cap in hand and very grateful for what it manages to dole out to them. Er, no, actually. The parents themselves have the duty of educating their children as Catholics by virtue of their covenantal promises made to God on the day of their marriage. So, even Catholic schools stand in loco parentis. The parents are NOT, therefore, clients of the school; the Catholic school is, in a sense, the subcontractor of Catholic parents. But could not the diocese defend its position on the grounds that it is arguing for the rights of children whose parents cannot or will not act in their defence? No! Because that is a different function from standing in the place of parents who actually, really, actively want a Catholic education for their children.
Even though the physical property of most schools belongs to the diocese, it is still the laity who gave the money that bought the property in the first place. It's interesting that as soon as the liberal agenda is threatened, certain people are suddenly no longer interested in "empowering those at a local level" or letting "the voice of the laity be heard" if it's not speaking from the approved "Catholic-lite" text. When those of us who are considered too "Traditional" or "conservative" quote the rules, the Catechism or the Code of Canon Law, sighs are let out, eyebrows are raised and we are treated as pariahs, hopelessly embroiled in a legalistic attitude to the Church, pastorally out of touch. Quotes from the Gospels about scribes and Pharisees come coughing up from the aghast lips of the modern, pastorally sensitive and (empty) church brigade. But suddenly, the "rules" and what property belongs to whom, becomes very important and those who usually look disapprovingly on such things become only to keen to quote them when it suits.

In the Archdiocese here in Liverpool, as the change in the timeline of the Sacraments of Initiation comes into force, a re-emphasis is being placed on the parents as the primary educators of their children in the Faith - recognising that relying on Catholic schools over the past forty years has been an utter failure. How we are to re-educate parents in order to pass on a Faith they barely posses themselves has yet to be explained. We are promised "resources" to help us accomplish this. My own attempts in the past when dealing with parents in their role of passing on the faith to their children have met with a frosty reception. I can only think it will have to begin at some very basic level as my experience is that many of these non-practising parents have a lamentable understanding of the Faith and what little they have is incoherent, contradictory and idiosyncratic.

Last year for the First Communion Preparation I gave no prepared input but asked parents to fill in a quiz/questionnaire about the Faith and their understanding of it. To call most of the responses "Modernist" would lend them a connection with the Faith that Pope Pius X would certainly not uphold. There were parents who boldly stated that they do not believe in de fide Dogmas of the Church, or the necessity of attending Holy Mass on Sundays. Apart from the few parents who actually attend Holy Mass regularly (whose answers showed a good grasp of the Faith), the rest expressed views which were riddled with relativism and individualism - one parent who admitted knowing that missing Mass on Sunday was a sin yet wrote “I don’t think you need to go to church to be a good Catholic”, another claimed that because he/she didn’t “like” certain things they shouldn’t happen! The comments revealed a very flawed understanding of Priesthood and ecclesiology; an attempt to remake the Faith in our own image - rather than to conform ourselves to the Faith.

So, it will have to start with the basics presented in a clear and non-fuzzy manner. But it is just the lack of such an approach that has landed us where we are. In the apparitions of Our Lady of Good Help in the Diocese of Green Bay, USA, (apparitions now recognised by the Church) the Blessed Virgin called for children to be educated in the Faith:

'Gather the children in this wild country and teach them what they should know for salvation’
How should this be accomplished? According the Our Blessed Mother:

'Teach the children the Catechism and show them how to make the Sign of the Cross. Teach them how to approach the Sacraments.'

I can sympathise with the parents who want a properly Catholic education for their children at the Vaughan. I have personally experienced great resistance and a concerted effort at official and unofficial levels to prevent me when I ask for basic Church rules to apply in our Catholic school. No-one is interested in promoting the teachings of the Church because most of those involved - teachers, governors and parents - are either so far from the Faith that they are not interested in such things or they are positively resistant to any affirmation of what are considered traditional Church teaching. If only I had the hundreds of parents who were of like mind to those at the Vaughan!

To go back to the comments Ches has made:

Should the Catholic school be a safety-net for children whose parents have lapsed? No! The school is only indirectly a tool for evangelisation; its primary function is building up the faith of those who are already faithful. That is not elitist, anymore than the fact parents feed their own children before feeding anyone else means that they are inegalitarian! If the diocese wishes to evangelise the lapsed, then let the diocese create its own opportunities for doing so, and let it not piggy-back on the efforts of faithful parents to educate their children in an atmosphere of fidelity and love.

Thursday, 17 February 2011

Happy motoring!



The picture above is a close-up. You can see where this driver broke through the guardrail, on the right side of the culvert, where the people are standing on the road, pointing.

The pick-up was traveling about 75 mph from right to left when it crashed through the guardrail.

It flipped end-over-end bounced off and across the culvert outlet, and landed right side up on the left side of the culvert, facing the opposite direction from which the driver was traveling.

The 22-year-old driver and his 18-year-old passenger were unhurt except for minor cuts and bruises. This happened just outside Flagstaff , AZ , on U.S. Hwy 100.

Now click on the full picture below...



As the friend who sent me the picture said:
If God isn’t done with you, God isn’t done with you….

Tuesday, 15 February 2011

The Mass - ever ancient, ever new

My profound thanks to Fr Tim Finigan for his article in "Usus Antiquior" - "Mutual Enrichment in theory and in practice" which you can read here.
(I found the link on Rorate Caeli.)

For many priests who celebrate the traditional form of the Roman Rite as well as the new and find its gestures and genius a genuine help to praying the Mass, there is sometimes a perceived difficulty in the desire to transmit some of the gestures and accouterments of the older form into the new. We are reminded by others that we are not supposed to "mix and match". I have found that the more familiar I become with the older form the stronger is the desire to bring some of its strengths into the new to enrich it but being by nature obedient to the rules, I have held back from this in many instances or carried them out with a slight sense that I might be breaking the rules.

Fr Finigan mentions some practices that are in fact a part of the Ordinary Form and specified in the Missal but have been often neglected - for example the bow of the head at the name of the Blessed Trinity, Our Lord, Our Lady and the saint of the day (275a in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal) or the first option mentioned of saying the Offertory prayers inaudibly. The always allowed possibility of offering Mass ad orientem. The EF can remind us of these neglected parts of the OF. Personally, I have either always done these things or have done for some time but others that are directly lifted from the Extraordinary Form I have only done such are not much seen by the people (silent prayers of the priest) - feeling, as I say, some hesitation.

Fr Finigan has laid my fears to rest! My thanks to him. I urge all priests to read this excellent article which seems to me to be so much in tune with the Holy Father's obvious intentions.

Fr Tim Finigan offers Mass in his Parish Church

Monday, 14 February 2011

St Valentine

TO ALL YOU LOVERS OUT THERE

HAPPY ST VALENTINE'S DAY




Thank you to Br Lawrence Lew OP for the photo and a little info on St Valentine.

Actually, in the Ordinary Form Calendar we are not celebrating St Valentine but Ss Cyril and Methodius. It struck me as a missed opportunity that the secular world is still celebrating the remnants of a culture that was once based on the Church and the Christian Faith but that because we have changed our ancient practice we no longer have that link with which to engage the world - in what could be a very positive way in regards to St Valentine.

Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi spoke of the need for more profound dialogue with non-believers in an interview last week with Vatican Radio (read it here). The Cardinal is speaking of quite elevated academic dialogue but it also has to be engaging in the real world of popular culture that the majority of men and women experience in our society. Many non-believers are celebrating St Valentine's day with a loved one - an ideal point from which to begin dialogue but one that we have lost because we don't actually keep that feast any more.

We tinker with our Tradition at our peril, as the Venerable Pope Pius XII, of happy memory, once wrote:

"I hear around me partisans of novelties who want to demolish the Holy Sanctuary, destroy the universal flame of the Church, reject her adornments, and make her remorseful for her historical past. Well, my dear friend, I am convinced that the Church of Peter must affirm her past, or else she will dig her own tomb."

(Georges Roche & Philippe Saint Germain, Pie XII devant l'Histoire, Paris: Robert Lafont, 1972, p. 52-53).

Sunday, 13 February 2011

Catholic (?) Schools

...despite being a practising a Catholic?

On Radio 4 this morning the completely un-biased and Catholic-friendly "Sunday" programme aired a piece about the Cardinal Vaughan Schooll in London. (Linen on the Hedgerow has a post about it as well.) I can't understand the strangeness of what was said. The school is recognised by the government's inspection body (OFSTED) as a "highly motivated and highly achieving Catholic School". The Archdiocese of Westminster seems to think that its entrance criteria are too demanding but as one of the parents pointed out, what the school asks for is nothing more than what any and every Catholic is supposed to be doing anyway. It seems that practising the Faith is now, in the eyes of the Archdiocese, a bar to attending a Catholic school, or at the very least something not to be encouraged. Surely, this is the inversion of what should be desirable?

Bishop Stack, defending the Archdiocesan position, says that the criteria imposed by the school might prevent ethnic minorities and immigrants from attending. However, the school has forty - yes forty - different ethnic groups represented among its pupils.

Bishop Stack also says that adding such conditions (the normal ones the Church imposes on every Catholic at Baptism) "makes things less clear". To my mind it couldn't make things any clearer. The school says "we ask of you what the Church asks of you". Seems clear to me.

Professor Gerald Grace, Director of the Centre for Research in Catholic Education and of the Institute of Education at the University of London says that a modern Catholic school is about being "open and hospitable to the lapsed". But my dear Professor, what about being open and hospitable to the practising Catholics - the forgotten minority? Those who are lapsed are in sin, in an irregular relationship with the Church and its teaching. Those who are practising are also sinners but they are, by the Church's own legal, pastoral and moral standards also in a regular relationship with the Church (ie sinners who go to Confession).

Perhaps the real reason for the uncomfortable shifting and tenuous argument is that if ALL Catholic schools began asking families to do what the Church asks of every baptised Catholic the vast majority of our schools would not be full, like the Vaughan, but empty. At least in the short term but in the end perhaps we would have many fewer Catholic schools but much better Catholic schools.

In other words, they would be what is says they are on the sign at the gate - CATHOLIC.

Friday, 11 February 2011

"Let me entertain you" - or "Let us pray"?

Across on Countercultural father on a post about the Methodist "ordinations" at Liverpool's Catholic Cathedral (see also James Preece) a comment was made by Richard Collins (who's blog is always worth reading) ...

The thing that buzzes around in my head is WHY? Do they not have a Hall of their own to hold the service in?

As the above photos show, the Methodists did have a splendid hall. Grand Central Hall, a Grade II listed building, was opened in 1905 as the Central Hall of the Liverpool Wesleyan Mission, and had a capacity of 3,576 people. It seems to have been a little large for it's original use and was also used from its opening until at least 1944 as the New Century Picture Hall cinema.

In the Liverpool Echo, dated 28 October 1922, the mixing of religious services with cinema shows was explained thus by the Reverend T.A. Turney:
"Cinematograph entertainments are given every Saturday night from the first Saturday in October to the last in March. They were designed to introduce "down-and-outers" to the (Methodist) Mission. Our prices of admission are 3d and 5d. We have an organ recital, a hymn, and short prayer, and then a concert, followed by one long picture.
"Though we select our pictures very carefully, we have no difficulty in finding those of the right type. The films include such as "Torn Sails", "All Sorts and Conditions of Men", by Walter Besant, and "Andy Hardy"."We have very large crowds at the concerts, and also at the Sunday night services. We can seat 2300, but often we are packed so early that I have to begin the service a quarter of an hour before time.
"As I have said, the concerts and services are designed for those whom others might term "undesirables", and a great deal of good is being done."

From 1933 to 1939 the hall was the home of the Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra while the Philharmonic Hall was rebuilt following a fire.

In 1990 the Methodists sold Central Hall and the building became the Barcelona bar and nightclub. A seemingly strange transaction considering the Methodists traditional disdain for alcohol! (Although we as Catholics are not guiltless in this - St Peter's in Seel Street, Liverpool (the oldest church in the city built in 1788) is now "Alma de Cuba" Bar
Here are some photos (from their "Vampire Carn-Evil" in October 2010) to give you some of the reasons why a sacred place should not be sold to the highest bidder.




But ... back to the Methodists. What it also shows is that the desire to attract people to religion by tossing in some entertainment doesn't really work - the Methodists have obviously been trying it since the 1920's and they no longer have their building or even the ambition and enthusiasm that led them to build such an impressive edifice. Putting on Mass with a Disco afterwards to lure in the young still doesn't work in our own day. The challenge of radical Catholicism - the fullness of the Faith - perhaps speaks more to idealistic young people looking for something different from what they see in the world around them; something that gives a strong group identity.

The Church should never say, "Let me entertain you" - it never works.
It should always say, "Let us pray" - that always works.

Thursday, 10 February 2011

Rome Diocese Launches John Paul II Web Page


The Diocese of Rome has launched a Web site dedicated to the beatification of Pope John Paul II, which takes place on May 1st.

Zenit reports that:
"Named Ioannes Paulus P.P. II, the site will gather information on the beatification of the Pope, and make it available in six languages: English, Spanish, French, Polish, Italian and Romanian.

The endeavor will also post information on the life of Karol Wojtyla, his thought and his devotion of Mary, the Mother of God, as well as the process of his canonization cause, and other events linked to the May 1 beatification. It will also offer documentation on the initiatives around the world that will surround the Pontiff's beatification, and promote prayers of intercession and thanksgiving.

Additionally, the site links to "Totus Tuus," which is a monthly magazine dedicated to the the Pope's cause of canonization."

This is one to add to the blogroll, methinks.